Fritzing vs eagle11/14/2022 ![]() ![]() Very nice concept, but it also seemed to have a lot of limitations. You can follow circuits created by other people, fork your own variants of other people’s circuits etc. Mix schematic editor with GitHub and you get something like Circuits.io. The verdicts below are instead based on 15-20 minutes use of each service, and no reading of any manuals or help pages. Disclaimer: Nothing near a full review was made of the different services. In particular I thought the more basic editors sounded promising – let’s give them a try. Still, it is usually still seen as the best software for this kind of work.īut maybe there are other options. I have never really used CadSoft Eagle enough to get comfortable with it, and whenever I used it it seemed to be overkill for what I wanted to do. Less consumer confusion.During the recent work on the one dollar variable fan controller, I looked into options for documenting the work. Jameco offers 5 options in 1K ohm through hole resistors, and they're different wattages. Resistor Carbon Film 1k Ohm 1/4 Watt 5%". "Stackpole CF14JT1K00, 1 kOhms ±5% 0.25W, 1/4W Through Hole Resistor Axial Flame Retardant Coating, Safety Carbon Film."Ĭompare Jameco. The cheapest resistor is $0.10 each, $1.62 for 100. 96 remaining, any of which would probably work on your solderless breadboard. You probably don't want the $50 ultra-precision 0.01% resistors, so set the precision to 1% or worse. Select wattage ratings under 1 watt, and you're down to 124 options. If you know to select "Cut Tape" and "Bulk", meaning you don't want reels of components for an automated production line, you're down to 199. Select "Active" and "In Stock", and you're down to 299 remaining. Yes, DigiKey offers 2,261 different 1K resistors. You get back "Chip Resistor - Surface Mount (508794 items), Through Hole Resistors (285766 items)". It's like the experience hobbyists have when they encounter Digi-Key. ![]() Fritzling is limited enough to be approachable. You start them up, and there you are, with a blank schematic and no idea how to get started. Real EDA programs are terrifying to beginners. The ceiling is low, but high enough for many projects. It's for the Arduino crowd.įritzing is for projects that can be built on standard solderless breadboards. Fritzing is a piece of software that should be expunged from the Internet.Īw, Fritzing is cute. Recommending Fritzing to someone 'to make their first PCB' or 'to learn circuits' does them a disservice. I believe the authors of Fritzing have never used another EDA suite, and it shows. ![]() Anyone looking to design a PCB should look at literally any other software besides Fritzing. Unfortunately, that's the only thing it can do well. There are several dozen other shortcomings in Fritzing, but these are the worst faults.įritzing is a good tool for what it is designed to do: create graphics of breadboard layouts. I will assume from this the efforts for support and documentation are effectively dead. That part of the FAQ has changed, but there are still no links official tutorials for - or even links to third-party tutorials available elsewhere on the Internet - on the official Fritzing site. Regarding the last point: until very recently, the official Fritzing FAQ stated creating custom parts was impossible. Every other EDA suite can create custom parts without an external tool. You can create custom parts in Fritzing, but you have to use Inkscape, Illustrator, or another vector design program. No, I don't mean re-labeling pins on packages, like what the Fritzing tutorials tell you to do. Compare that with something sensible, like Red and Green for KiCad, or Red and Blue for Eagle.ĭespite conventional wisdom, you can create custom parts in Fritzing. Rotations must be done through a contextual menu.įor PCB design: the color for the top layer of copper is yellow, and the color for the bottom layer of copper is a slightly darker yellow. You cannot rotate a part by right clicking, or through keyboard commands. You can't name connections in a Fritzing schematic. It's truly idiotic if you've ever used any other EDA suite. That is, you can't 'tap into' a wire, like you could with a net. Furthermore, the design philosophy of Fritzing schematics is, 'wires between pins' instead of nets between pins. You can only draw straight lines between nodes in a schematic. Schematic capture in Fritzing is, in short, terrible. Yeah, you can do it, but it's the wrong tool for the job. emacs argument, either: Fritzing is like using a crescent wrench to drive a nail. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |